YES
The Individual Mandate IS Constitutional
(each video is less than 2 minutes)
Reasons for Individual Mandate
|
Commerce and Revenue Clauses
|
Commerce Clause Precedents
|
Limiting Principles
|
UPDATE: Supreme Court Decision
On June 28, 2012 Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for the majority, stated that the individual mandate was constitutional, not under Congress’ power to regulate commerce but to tax (Article 1 Sec. 8). Listen to the audio of the decision below.
Chief Justice John Roberts announces the Supreme Court's Decision
| NO
The Individual Mandate is NOT Constitutional
(each video is less than 2 minutes)
Commerce Clause |
Limiting Principles
|
 Limiting Principles |
Necessary and Proper Clause |
Discussion of Decision
Donald Verrilli, solicitor general who argued for the Individual Mandate
Michael Carvin, attorney for the National Federation of Independent Business, who argued against the Individual Mandate
|